1. Schneider from One Day at a Time
Schneider was the kind of building superintendent who felt more like a family member than a landlord, always popping into the apartment with advice no one asked for but everyone secretly benefitted from. His swagger, his tool belt, and his soft heart beneath the bravado made him one of the warmest side characters of the ’70s. You always got the sense that he had a whole other life outside the Harringtons’ apartment, filled with quirky friends and odd jobs. A spin-off could have easily leaned into his backstory, exploring who he was before he became the guy who could fix anything with a wrench and a smile. Audiences clearly adored him, and the chemistry he had with just about everyone made every scene pop. It felt like the writers knew how much viewers loved him because they kept expanding his role. That charm alone could’ve carried a whole series.
Schneider’s spin-off could have shown his relationships with the tenants who relied on him for everything from repairs to life advice. Imagine entire episodes dedicated to the strange maintenance requests he’d get or the neighbors he’d reluctantly help through personal crises. His combination of confidence and vulnerability made him the type of character you wanted to root for, even when he was being a little too nosy. And honestly, seeing Schneider manage a new building filled with even bigger personalities would’ve been sitcom gold. His tough-but-tender persona also left plenty of room for heartfelt stories. Add in a possible romantic arc, and you’ve got a show that writes itself. In many ways, he already felt like the star of his own world, just waiting for the spotlight.
2. Marcia Brady from The Brady Bunch
Marcia was the queen bee of the Brady household, balancing her academic success with school elections, cheerleading tryouts, and the everyday drama of being a teenager in a blended family. She had the personality, the confidence, and the comedic timing to anchor her own show. Watching her navigate high school life with her signature mix of charm and occasional overconfidence would’ve made for endlessly entertaining episodes. Plus, she always felt like she had her own orbit, one that often expanded beyond the Brady living room. A spin-off could’ve explored her world through her friendships, rivals, and ambitions. You just know she would’ve found herself in hilarious new situations every week. It’s surprising the studio never handed her a spotlight.
Her journey into early adulthood could’ve been even more fun, especially as she transitioned from self-assured teenager to young woman figuring out who she wanted to be. A college-set show with Marcia at the center would’ve offered a fresh take on her character while still keeping her dramatic flair intact. She had plenty of room to grow, and viewers would’ve followed her in a heartbeat. Seeing her manage new relationships or clash with tough professors feels like classic sitcom material. She also had the emotional depth to pull off heartfelt storylines. A Marcia-led show would’ve blended comedy and sincerity in a way that felt true to the era. She had everything she needed to shine on her own.
3. Reuben Kincaid from The Partridge Family
Reuben Kincaid constantly looked like he was one phone call away from a meltdown, yet he somehow held the entire Partridge operation together. His exasperation, paired with genuine affection for the family, made him one of the funniest parts of the show. A spin-off focused on his life as a perpetually stressed music manager would’ve been hilarious. There was so much potential in watching him juggle eccentric clients and chaotic situations. His character always hinted at a bigger world beyond the Partridge household. He also had a wonderful balance of crankiness and heart that made him instantly likable. You could practically see the comedic possibilities stacked a mile high.
Imagine him trying to guide a new, less wholesome band while longing for the Partridges’ chaos in a weirdly comforting way. That contrast alone would have been a great running gag. His interactions with other music-industry types could’ve opened the door to fresh stories. Plus, exploring his personal life might’ve added a new dimension to a character who was more complex than he seemed. His constant stress gave him a kind of underdog energy that made you root for him. A Reuben-centered series would’ve offered a witty, slightly frantic look at the entertainment business. He deserved his own stage just as much as the singing family he managed.
4. Florence Johnston from The Jeffersons
Florence’s razor-sharp wit and perfectly timed quips made her a standout every time she entered the Jeffersons’ apartment. She was never afraid to call things exactly as she saw them, creating some of the show’s most memorable comedic moments. A spin-off built around her life outside the Jeffersons’ home could’ve offered a whole new perspective on her no-nonsense personality. She clearly had stories of her own, and audiences would’ve loved to see what her world looked like when she wasn’t bantering with George. Her humor had a warmth behind it, revealing a character who cared deeply but masked it with sarcasm. That blend of honesty and charm was perfect for a series built around her. It’s surprising no one ever pushed for it.
A deeper look into Florence’s personal life could’ve been incredibly fun, especially as she navigated friendships, dating, and tough situations with her trademark deadpan delivery. A workplace comedy set in a new household or environment could’ve given her even more people to spar with. Her character had endless potential for both laughs and heartfelt moments. There’s something irresistible about someone who stands her ground while delivering iconic one-liners. She always felt like she carried her own show’s energy even in short appearances. Watching her handle new challenges would’ve been delightful. She’s one of those characters viewers always wanted more of.
5. Alice from Alice
While Alice Hyatt was the show’s lead, the supporting cast was so strong that Flo often gets the spin-off credit. But Alice herself had plenty of untapped potential for her own story. Her resilience as a single mom and her quiet strength made her incredibly compelling. A solo series focusing on her life beyond the diner could’ve tapped into emotional and comedic moments with ease. She was warm, grounded, and full of personality, even when the story wasn’t fully centered on her. And there was still so much more to explore about her dreams and ambitions. A spotlight on Alice could’ve carried a more heartfelt sitcom with plenty of charm.
Following Alice as she rebuilt her life in a new setting would’ve made for great TV, especially as she chased her musical aspirations. There was always a sense that she had more to say and more to discover. Giving her a new environment, fresh faces, and different challenges could’ve shown sides of her character that remained just out of reach. Her sincerity made her instantly relatable to viewers. She deserved a chance to explore her identity outside the diner walls. A character as layered as Alice could’ve easily sustained a long-running series. She had the heart and the humor to lead it.
6. Radar O’Reilly from M*A*S*H
Radar was one of those characters who somehow managed to be both hilarious and deeply touching from one scene to the next. His innocence and intuition made him a standout, even among a large ensemble of unforgettable personalities. A spin-off following him after his departure from the 4077th would’ve been fascinating. There was already a built-in arc of growth and transition that audiences were eager to see. Watching him adjust to civilian life opened the door for heartfelt storytelling. His gentle nature gave him a timeless appeal that resonated with viewers. It’s almost surprising that no one grabbed the chance to keep following his journey.
A Radar-focused series could’ve explored his attempts to find normalcy after the war. His quirky habits and big heart would have created endless opportunities for humor. At the same time, the emotional weight of his experiences offered space for more grounded moments. He was the kind of character who connected with people instantly. Seeing him forge new friendships or navigate unfamiliar situations would’ve made for warm, character-driven episodes. His story didn’t end when he left camp, and a spin-off could’ve given him the continuation he deserved. There was so much more to tell.
7. Juan Epstein from Welcome Back, Kotter
Epstein always felt like a character bubbling with energy, humor, and untapped storylines. His mix of charm and rebellious streak made him one of the most memorable Sweathogs. A spin-off focusing on his life outside the classroom could’ve shown more of what shaped his personality. He had a unique way of seeing the world and bringing levity to even awkward situations. His character always hinted at deeper layers beneath the jokes. With his quick wit and strong presence, he easily could’ve carried a series. His life in Brooklyn would’ve offered so many comedic opportunities.
Exploring Epstein’s home life and neighborhood could’ve brought in a colorful cast of new characters. His interactions with his eccentric family alone could fill episodes. A job, a romantic storyline, or any new adventure would’ve allowed him to grow beyond the Sweathog identity. His humor had a real sense of authenticity. Audiences loved watching his antics, but they also cared about him as a person. Giving him a show would’ve let viewers see him mature while keeping the humor that made him iconic. He was ready for the spotlight.
8. Larry Dallas from Three’s Company
Larry Dallas was the charming troublemaker who always managed to stir the pot, often without even meaning to. His antics created some of the show’s funniest misunderstandings. A spin-off centered on his wild dating life or his used-car business could’ve been a riot. He had the charisma and comedic instincts to carry a series filled with chaotic adventures. Larry constantly found himself in absurd scenarios, which is basically the foundation of any good sitcom. Even when he messed up, you couldn’t help but like him. That lovable rascal energy had staying power.
A show following Larry could’ve easily leaned into his over-the-top personality while still showing glimpses of vulnerability. Watching him navigate relationships, friendships, and his own ego would’ve been endlessly entertaining. His chemistry with the original cast hinted at how well he could work with a brand-new ensemble. Each episode could’ve shown him trying to outsmart situations that quickly spiraled out of control. His heart was usually in the right place, even if his plans weren’t. That blend of humor and heart made him spin-off material. Larry’s world was chaotic in the best possible way.
9. Horshack from Welcome Back, Kotter
Horshack’s high-pitched laugh and sweet, earnest personality made him instantly recognizable on screen. He was quirky, innocent, and oddly profound when he wanted to be. A spin-off following his life after high school could’ve offered a fresh, heartfelt perspective. His character always seemed like someone trying to find his place in the world. Watching him grow into adulthood would’ve been both funny and meaningful. He had a gentleness that stood out among the Sweathogs. There was something magnetic about his awkward honesty.
Seeing Horshack navigate jobs, relationships, and the real world could’ve brought in plenty of new comedic situations. He had a way of stumbling into awkward moments that became unexpectedly touching. Giving him space to shine on his own would’ve let audiences see more of his unique worldview. His optimism and vulnerability made him incredibly relatable. He was the kind of character who always tried his best, even when he didn’t succeed. A spin-off would’ve allowed him to stumble, grow, and charm viewers all at once. Horshack absolutely deserved his own show.
10. Arnold Jackson from Diff’rent Strokes
Arnold’s charisma and comedic timing were undeniable, even among the strong cast around him. His catchphrases, expressions, and quick wit made him the breakout star from the moment he arrived. A spin-off centered on him as he grew older could’ve shown a whole new side of his character. Fans adored him, and his popularity alone could’ve fueled a successful series. His mischievous but lovable persona had endless story potential. Watching him take on bigger challenges would’ve felt like a natural evolution. He had that rare ability to be funny and heartfelt at the same time.
A coming-of-age spin-off would’ve given Arnold room to grow while staying true to the character people loved. Seeing him handle school, friendships, and everyday problems would’ve made for a strong sitcom. His personality was made for both comedy and meaningful moments. He also had a tendency to say exactly what everyone else was thinking, creating plenty of great dialogue. A new show could’ve built on that strength with more mature humor as he aged. Arnold had the spark and the staying power to make it work. He more than earned the chance.
11. Lenny and Squiggy from Laverne & Shirley
Lenny and Squiggy were the ultimate comedic duo, popping into scenes with unforgettable entrances and perfectly ridiculous lines. Their chemistry was so natural that it often felt like they were improvising, even when they weren’t. A spin-off with the two of them at the center could’ve been outrageous in the best way. They had a style of humor that was both silly and clever, which made them instantly memorable. Every episode could’ve followed them through bizarre schemes and oddball adventures. Their personalities were tailor-made for a quirky sitcom. They were scene-stealers every time.
A spin-off exploring their friendship and misadventures would’ve been pure fun. Whether they were chasing odd jobs, running a strange business, or accidentally landing in trouble, viewers would’ve followed them anywhere. Their dynamic had the heart of a buddy comedy paired with classic ’70s sitcom energy. Introducing new characters for them to clash or bond with would’ve added even more variety. They had the comedic range to carry both broad slapstick and sincere moments. Lenny and Squiggy’s world was already hilarious in the margins. Imagine how much better it could’ve been front and center.
12. Julie Cooper from The Love Boat
Julie brought warmth, kindness, and a sense of calm to the constantly changing world aboard the Pacific Princess. As cruise director, she interacted with every guest and crew member, making her one of the show’s most versatile characters. A spin-off focused on her life between voyages or managing a different cruise line could’ve offered so many unique storylines. She had a steady charm that made viewers feel instantly comfortable. Julie also had a great balance of wisdom and humor that made her scenes memorable. There was always a hint of untapped depth beneath her sunny exterior. She easily could’ve anchored her own series.
Watching Julie navigate new ports, new passengers, and new challenges would’ve been a natural extension of what fans already loved. Her role gave her access to people’s hopes, dramas, and triumphs, which could’ve made for character-driven episodes. A spin-off could’ve leaned more into her relationships and personal growth. She always seemed like someone trying to find balance in a job that demanded constant emotional labor. That alone is rich storytelling material. Julie had the heart, humor, and relatability needed to lead a show. She was the quiet standout who deserved a larger spotlight.
