Elizabeth Montgomery captured hearts in Hollywood with her enchanting performance on Bewitched, but behind the scenes, her love life was anything but magical. She walked down the aisle four times, enduring heartbreak and turmoil before finally finding lasting happiness. Some believe her struggles stemmed from a complicated relationship with her father, actor Robert Montgomery, who reportedly resented her success. Whether it was a subconscious search for the love she never received from him or just a case of bad luck in romance, Elizabeth’s journey to true love was long and filled with surprises.
1. Frederick Gallatin Cammann Wanted a Housewife, Not a Star
Elizabeth’s first marriage was to New York socialite Frederick Gallatin Cammann in 1954, but it didn’t take long to realize they had very different ideas about their future. Fred wanted a traditional wife, someone who would fit into high society without causing a stir. But Elizabeth wasn’t built for quiet domestic life—she had big Hollywood dreams. When she made it clear that she wasn’t giving up her career, the marriage quickly fell apart. Just one year after tying the knot, they were divorced. While it was a brief union, it was a sign of things to come: Elizabeth wasn’t the type to settle for a love that didn’t fit her ambitions.
2. Gig Young: A Rebellious Choice That Ended in Heartache
Only a year after her first divorce, Elizabeth married Oscar-winning actor Gig Young in 1956. But this marriage wasn’t just about love—it was also about rebellion. Gig was much older than Elizabeth, closer to her father’s age, which reportedly infuriated Robert Montgomery. In a way, Elizabeth seemed to enjoy upsetting her father with this relationship, especially since he had approved of her first husband. However, Gig was dealing with severe personal demons. He reportedly battled alcoholism and possible undiagnosed bipolar disorder, making their marriage an emotional roller coaster. Geoffrey Mark, a pop culture historian, later described him as “extraordinarily handsome, yet extraordinarily immature.” After seven turbulent years, Elizabeth decided she had had enough. She filed for divorce in 1963, unwilling to continue the cycle of instability she had grown up with.
3. William Asher: Love, Work, and a Family on Bewitched
While going through her divorce from Gig Young, Elizabeth worked on the 1963 film Johnny Cool, directed by William Asher. Sparks flew, but there was one complication—Bill Asher was still married. Their romance moved quickly, and when Elizabeth became pregnant with his child, they tied the knot that same year. This was the relationship that seemed to change everything for her. Bill not only became her husband but also her creative partner, directing and producing Bewitched. Together, they had three children, and for a while, their life seemed picture-perfect. However, as Bewitched soared in popularity, their marriage started to crumble. Elizabeth felt creatively stifled, and Bill was consumed by work. By the time the show ended in 1972, their marriage was also falling apart. Both had been unfaithful, and eventually, Elizabeth left, causing a painful rift between her and her family. After a year of separation, she briefly considered returning to Bill, but the damage was too deep. Their divorce was finalized in 1974.
4. Robert Foxworth: Her True Love, Found at Last
After three failed marriages, Elizabeth swore off the idea of ever walking down the aisle again. But then she met actor Robert Foxworth, and everything changed. Their connection was immediate, and unlike her past relationships, this one wasn’t built on drama or rebellion—it was simply love. Still, Elizabeth remained hesitant about marriage. It took Robert two decades of patient devotion to convince her to give it another try. Finally, in 1993, after twenty years together, Elizabeth and Robert tied the knot. It was the happiest and most stable relationship of her life. They remained together until Elizabeth’s untimely passing in 1995, proving that sometimes, the best love stories take a little longer to unfold.
Elizabeth Montgomery’s journey to love was anything but simple, but in the end, she found what she had been searching for: a partner who truly understood her. After years of heartbreak and searching, she finally got her happily ever after.
