12 Most Absurd things about Gilligan’s Island

Looking back at Gilligan’s Island, we have to admit that the show was a wacky, endearing piece of 60s and 70s TV history. It didn’t always make sense—actually, it rarely did—but that’s what made it so much fun to watch. We tuned in for the slapstick humor, outlandish scenarios, and, let’s face it, the utter absurdity of it all. Here are 12 things that make us shake our heads today, but that we loved back then.

1. Ginger’s Unending Supply of Makeup

GILLIGAN’S ISLAND, Tina Louise, 1964-1967.

How did Ginger always manage to look like a Hollywood starlet, even after being stranded for years? Her makeup was always on point, her hair never out of place, and she never seemed to break a sweat, even when the rest of the cast was sweating in the sun. Whatever beauty routine she had going on was next-level.

2. How Did They Pack So Much for a “Three-Hour Tour”?

GILLIGAN’S ISLAND, Natalie Schafer, 1964-1967

Let’s start with the basics. The castaways were on a short boat ride, yet somehow the Howells brought an entire wardrobe of fancy clothes, Mary Ann had enough cute dresses to last a year, and Ginger’s gowns looked like she was always ready for the red carpet. Who packs that much for a three-hour tour?

3. A Radio That Never Died

GILLIGAN’S ISLAND, (from left): Dawn Wells, Tina Louise, Russell Johnson, Jim Backus, Natalie Schafer, Alan Hale Jr., 1964-67.

The trusty transistor radio was the island’s sole connection to the outside world—and it never seemed to run out of batteries. How on earth could a small radio work for years without fresh batteries or a power source? Clearly, that little device was the most durable piece of tech ever made.

4. The Professor’s Wildly Selective Genius

GILLIGAN’S ISLAND, Russell Johnson, 1964-1967

The Professor could build a bamboo lie detector, create a washing machine out of coconuts, and fix the radio a thousand times. But somehow, he couldn’t fix the boat? Not even a raft to get them off the island? You’d think a man with that level of ingenuity could solve the one big problem that really mattered.

5. That Mysterious Island Weather

GILLIGAN’S ISLAND, Bob Denver, (1964), 1964-1967. ph: Richard R. Hewett / TV Guide / courtesy Everett Collection

The weather on the island was…confusing, to say the least. One moment it was tropical paradise, and the next, a raging storm would appear out of nowhere. And somehow, despite all the cyclones and hurricanes, nothing was ever damaged beyond repair—except maybe their hopes of leaving.

6. No One Could Recognize Them!

GILLIGAN’S ISLAND, from left, Dawn Wells, Bob Denver, 1964-67 (1964 photo). ph: Ron Thal / TV Guide / courtesy Everett Collection

Despite being stranded for so long and having numerous visitors (aliens, other castaways, and even celebrities), no one back on the mainland seemed to be looking for these seven people. It was as if they were all completely forgotten by the world—even though there were newspaper stories about them in earlier episodes!

7. Visitors Who Just… Left?

GILLIGAN’S ISLAND, from left, Dawn Wells, Natalie Schafer, Jim Backus, writer and producer Sherwood Schwartz, (at typewriter), Alan Hale, Jr., Bob Denver (in bucket hat), Tina Louise, Russell Johnson, on-set, 1964-67 (1965 photo). ph: Ivan Nagy / TV Guide / courtesy Everett Collection

Speaking of visitors, how many people showed up on the island, hung out with the castaways, and then left without offering to help them get home? Time and time again, some random person would show up, spend a few days, and then leave, somehow always managing to miss the part where the castaways needed a ride.

8. The Banana Cream Pies

YouTube

The island was supposedly uninhabited, yet there was never a shortage of bananas, coconuts, or the ingredients for pie. Mary Ann baked an impressive number of banana cream pies with what seemed like an endless supply of ingredients. Who needs a store when you’ve got an island with a bakery’s worth of goods?

9. The Unexplained Shark Repellent

YouTube

In one episode, the Professor whips up some shark repellent—out of what, exactly? It’s never really explained. He just suddenly has it. How did he know how to make it? And, more importantly, why didn’t he use that brainpower to get them off the island sooner?

10. Gilligan’s Untouchable Hat

YouTube

No matter what happened, Gilligan’s iconic white hat never came off. He could be swept into the ocean, fall out of a tree, or get hit by coconuts, but that hat stayed glued to his head like it was the most indestructible thing on the planet. It was as much a part of him as his goofy charm.

11. The Island’s Ever-Changing Geography

GILLIGAN’S ISLAND, on set, 1964-1967. ph: Richard R. Hewett / TV Guide / Courtesy Everett Collection

One episode, the island seemed small enough to walk across in a few hours, while in another, it had caves, lagoons, mountains, and forests big enough to get lost in for days. It was like the island itself had its own scriptwriter, changing size and terrain to fit the plot of the week.

12. No One Ever Aged

GILLIGAN’S ISLAND, back from left: Jim Backus, Natalie Schafer, Tina Louise, Alan Hale, Jr., Dawn Wells; front from left: Russell Johnson, Bob Denver, 1964-1967

Despite being stranded for what seemed like years, no one ever got older. The Howells were perpetually the same well-dressed older couple, Ginger and Mary Ann were always youthful, and even the Professor never seemed to grow a single gray hair. It’s like time stopped on the island, making it even more surreal.

The absurdities of Gilligan’s Island were exactly what made the show so unforgettable. Sure, none of it made much sense, but that was the charm. It was a simpler time when we didn’t question things too much—we just went along for the ride, laughing at the antics of Gilligan and the gang. Looking back now, those absurdities make the show even more endearing. Would we have it any other way? Not a chance.

Scroll to Top